I was lucky enough to moderate a panel this morning at the CIO Summit which was being held in conjunction with Innotech in Portland, OR. The panel discussion was titled “Charting the Future of Open Source” and our panelists were top-notch:
- Jason Matusow, Program Manager of Shared Source, Microsoft
- Tim Witham, CTO, OSDL
- Daniel Frye, Vice President of LTC, IBM
- Matt Asay, Director, Linux Busines Office, Novell
Now, it’s pretty tough to do much of anything in just an hour and I’m pretty sure we didn’t exactly chart the future of open source, however, there was some great discussion and I learned quite a bit about moderating a panel such as this:
- Avoid drinking 4 cups of coffee before moderating a panel; you want to avoid coming off looking like Beavis.
- Know when to say when; you can beat the TCO horse only so many times before people will get bored of it.
- Engaged audiences are the best; we had fantastic questions from the CIO’s in the audience like PSU’s Mark Gregory and Oregon’s Department of Human Services Bill Crowell.
- I had to dock a few points off of folks scores for shameless plugs of their products or initiatives; myself included.
There was one particular discussion that occurred around communities and innovation. Jason was arguing that innovation simply cannot come from communities; there is no financial motivation for them to want to innovate. Matt somewhat agreed there and said that even the innovation that we’re seeing across “communities” is really just focused around a few key developers.
Looking at the Firefox phenomenon and more importantly its impact on Microsoft has to make me wonder though. Here is an application that was spearheaded by a few individuals that wanted to make a better browser. Microsoft had all but given up the browser game because they had completely dominated it. What is the incentive for them to innovate? Along comes Firefox and its grassroots efforts and 37 million downloads later, Microsoft has had to changes its tune. So much so that last month they announced that IE 7.0 would be decoupled from the Windows operating system and would be released well before Longhorn. The innovations around Firefox are what helped force Microsoft’s hand. The community around Firefox is what will set it apart from anything that IE can do (because you know pop-up blocker and tabbed browing are the first things that will get implemented in the next release).
Dan was his usual solid self. When asked a question about options for consolidating databases in the near future (instead of having so many today) he simply replied, “You will always have choice. That’s it.” Dan is a rock and he has done a tremendous job of not only “getting it” but helping IBM to do the same.
All in all it was a good panel. I would have loved to talk some trash during the panel but thought I should just let the other guys have the floor; nobody was there to see me … haha … 